Two TPE samples can carry the same nominal Shore A hardness and still feel different in a finished grip. Wall thickness, surface texture, colour, the rigid substrate and moulding conditions all affect what the buyer sees and touches. A comparison therefore needs finished parts made under recorded conditions. This guide is a practical trial scorecard for buyers who already have a drawing or tool and want to compare candidate TPE granules fairly.
Set one reference before changing grades
Choose a reference part and agree who will approve it. Record the drawing revision, rigid substrate grade, insert preparation, mould, TPE wall thickness, colour and surface texture. If the part is assembled rather than overmoulded, state that at the outset: bonding checks will differ. Keep a retained reference sample and photograph it under consistent lighting.
Ask the supplier to identify each candidate by sample code. Do not compare one supplier’s catalogue test bar with another supplier’s moulded grip. Catalogue hardness is useful for screening, but the finished part is the decision point.
Compare feel with a repeatable method
Describe what “soft touch” means for this part. The acceptance sheet might cover grip comfort, surface tack, recovery after squeezing, slipperiness when dry or wet, and any unwanted odour. Have the same reviewers handle samples in the same order and conditions, with codes hidden if possible. Record the observations instead of relying on an unqualified “better feel” comment.
Measure hardness using the agreed Shore scale, specimen thickness, conditioning time and test method. A thin overmoulded layer can feel firmer than a thick test specimen, even when the material grade is unchanged. Haishengda can discuss customised TPE hardness in the previously confirmed Shore A 20–100 range; the useful target still depends on the finished geometry and the buyer’s method.
Record the moulding window
For each run, note the TPE and substrate grade, storage or drying conditions, barrel and mould settings, injection speed, holding pressure, cooling time and any colour masterbatch. Record changes one at a time where practical. KRAIBURG TPE’s injection-moulding guide explains why part and gate design affect injection settings. Avient’s overmoulding processing guide identifies substrate, moisture, temperature, colour carrier and part design among the variables that can affect adhesion. Those guides describe their own materials and do not replace the data sheet for the specific grade being tested.
Do a short filling study before accepting an appearance result. Check short shots, flash, weld lines, sink, colour variation and surface marks. A defect caused by the tool or process should not automatically be attributed to the resin. Keep the process record with the labelled parts so a promising result can be reproduced.
Judge the finished part against its use
Check critical dimensions, assembly fit and appearance after the same conditioning period for every candidate. For an overmoulded part, agree on an adhesion or peel test suitable for the actual joint, and inspect corners and thin edges. Record the failure mode rather than only a pass/fail label. If the part must withstand cleaners, oils, outdoor exposure or repeated handling, define those exposure and ageing checks before declaring a winner. Do not infer suitability for medical or food contact from softness alone; request the documents required for the target market and application.
A simple trial record has five fields for each candidate: sample code, process settings, measured results, observed defects, and the next action. That action may be “retain as reference,” “repeat with a controlled process change,” or “reject against the agreed criterion.” This makes the second trial useful instead of starting over.
Send a useful sample request
When enquiring, send the part drawing, substrate grade, TPE layer thickness, target Shore A range, colour, surface and service requirements, intended moulding process, test criteria, expected quantity and destination. Ask which grade-specific technical and regulatory documents are available. For the existing range, see Haishengda TPE granules; send the brief through the contact form or WhatsApp. The grade, sample terms, packing and delivery should be confirmed for the actual project.